Go Darke

Light thinks it travels faster than anything but it is wrong. No matter how fast light travels, it finds the darkness has always got there first, and is waiting for it

Daily Journal, Ethics

Burn it down…

A trolley problem is usually defined as a thought experiment in ethics. Although it doesn’t necessarily have to involve a runaway trolley car. There are no perfect outcomes, or indeed right or wrong answers and there are usually persuasive arguments that can be made for either hypothetical decision.

thumb_firefighter-stairs-burning-building.jpg

Scenario #1

A building is on fire, there is a child on the second floor. Without thinking you rush into the inferno firmly intent on rescuing the child. Half way up the stairs you notice a priceless Rembrandt hanging on the wall. Do you can carry on, rescue the child or… do you save the irreplaceable masterpiece?

Scenario #2

A building is on fire, there are two children in the building.Without thinking you rush into the inferno firmly intent on rescuing the children. Half way up the stairs you realise the fire is out of control and you will only be able to rescue one child… armed with perfect knowledge you know that one child has an IQ of 140. The other sub 80. Which child do you save?

Scenario #3

A building is on fire, there are two children in the building.Without thinking you rush into the inferno firmly intent on rescuing the children. Half way up the stairs you realise the fire is out of control and you will only be able to rescue one child… armed with perfect knowledge you know that one child will one day cure cancer. The other child is your best friends kid. Which child do you save?

It doesn’t really matter what you answer. Unless you’re a sociopath its likely you are likely to be bothered by whatever choice you make….

I can’t overstate how much I love trolley problems. I’m especially fascinated by programmers who are going to have to teach self-driving cars the algorithms required to make life or death decisions. Does your self-driving car sacrifice you by smashing itself into a brick wall… or does it mow down the child that broke free from its mothers grasp and ran into the road?

Decisions, decisions… decided in 0.05 seconds.

What a great time to be alive that we can mull over such things 🙂

6 Comments

  1. jim-

    March 23, 2019 at 5:02 am

    I could try to rescue this blog or grab an endangered six-pack. Decisions decisions. Hehe. The real trolley problem to me has a simple answer. I let those that are firstly in harms way take the hit, no matter how many. They are already destined to meet death which I shall not interfere with the universe.

    1. Jo

      March 23, 2019 at 5:23 am

      Interesting. That is the rarer of the answers and justifications (for the original trolley problem I mean) Saving your blog should always be your top priority tho. I totally agree.

      1. jim-

        March 23, 2019 at 5:25 am

        I really never gave it much more thought than that. Seems fairly simple, but I’ve never really studied it much

      2. Jo

        March 23, 2019 at 5:40 am

        You’re just a natural at picking the path less travelled it seems. (which… is usually the harder path) Maybe you’re just a sucker for punishment though.

      3. jim-

        March 23, 2019 at 5:43 am

        Maybe. I torture myself everyday when I read this blog 🎯. Really, I have lived a very independent life…except religion. I think I have that all figured out now. Time to have some fun.

      4. Jo

        March 23, 2019 at 6:18 am

        True. There is definitely some form of psychosis is that…

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.